England’s rugby supporters are starting to dream of a future where Ireland and British & Irish Lions head coach Andy Farrell returns to take the reins, as Steve Borthwick finds himself under ever-increasing scrutiny.
RUCK’s Autumn Nations Series coverage is proudly powered by the My Name’5 Doddie Foundation, dedicated to creating a world free of MND. Join the the fight against MND here.
England’s recent results have sparked calls for change, and some passionate fans aren’t holding back.
England’s Autumn Shocker
The latest blow came at Allianz Stadium, where England fell to Australia in a thrilling 42-37 encounter. It was a game that kept everyone on edge, as England surged ahead by 12 points, then found themselves trailing by 10. Maro Itoje’s late heroics in the 78th minute, which briefly put England ahead 37-35, seemed to have sealed a much-needed victory.
But with the final play, four minutes into added time, Australia struck back. Len Ikitau broke open England’s defense and fed Max Jorgensen, who finished with a dramatic dive, leaving the crowd in stunned silence.
A Painful Record
England have now lost six out of their ten matches in 2024, including the last four in a row. This is their worst streak since 2018, and the frustration among fans is palpable. The back-to-back defeats to Australia and New Zealand have only heightened tensions.
“Borthwick Has to Go”
The calls for change have been loud and clear. One fan demanded: “Borthwick has to go before the 6 Nations! Preferably NOW! Recruit Sean Edwards, Andy Farrell, and the recently retired Marler as coaches. The game has moved on, Steve’s missed the transition. What do we need to beat the Boks and France? They are the benchmark!”
“Get Farrell In”
Another supporter made their preference obvious: “Andy Farrell, doubt we could get him but that’s who I’d like to see in charge.” It’s clear that Farrell, who has made waves with Ireland, is a name at the top of many wish lists.
Regret Over Letting Farrell Go
The frustration runs deeper. One fan lamented: “England have regretted letting Andy Farrell go for years. Do whatever it takes to get him back.” The sentiment of missed opportunity is echoed across social media platforms.
Doubts Over Borthwick’s Leadership
“Borthwick out of his depth, just a coach, not a head coach. Get Farrell in,” a voice rang out, summarizing the growing opinion that England’s current head coach lacks the necessary authority to lead.
A Hopeful Thought
Some fans are pinning their hopes on Farrell’s heritage: “Andy Farrell is English. Surely he wouldn’t turn the job down?!”It’s a point that raises the tantalizing prospect of Farrell returning to England, even if it feels like wishful thinking.
Missing Key Defensive Talent
Criticism of Borthwick has extended to the backroom shake-ups: “Borthwick should take responsibility; if he had created a stable work environment, Felix Jones, one of the best defensive coaches in the game, might have stayed.”
Lacking “Oomph”
And finally, a damning remark from another fan: “Their biggest regret will be letting Andy Farrell slide. I get they want an English coach in charge but there is just no oomph to them.”
The pressure is on, and the England camp will need more than just hope if they’re to turn things around.
NEXT ENGLAND HEAD COACH ODDS:
Below we look at the current bookies favourites to replace Borthwick.
Rob Baxter – 12/1
The long-serving Exeter Chiefs coach has built a highly successful team, guiding them from the Championship to European champions.
Although Baxter has expressed satisfaction with his role at Exeter, he remains open to discussing the England job. His experience is primarily at the club level, which might be a consideration for the RFU in selecting a national head coach.
Andy Farrell – 10/1
Ireland’s current head coach, Andy Farrell, would be a high-profile option for England, especially given his previous role as their defence coach from 2011 to 2015.
However, he is under contract with Ireland through 2025, and his departure following England’s disappointing 2015 World Cup could complicate a return to the RFU.
Ronan O’Gara – 6/1
The La Rochelle head coach has established himself as a respected leader in European rugby. O’Gara has previously expressed interest in the England role, but he has acknowledged the mental leap required to take on such a high-profile position.
Family considerations and alignment with England’s rugby leadership would be factors in his decision.
Michael Cheika – 5/1
An experienced international coach with stints leading Australia and Argentina, Michael Cheika brings tactical insight and adaptability.
His broad international background would offer England a fresh perspective from outside the English rugby system.
Stuart Lancaster – 2/1
Currently the frontrunner, Lancaster’s successful period with Leinster has boosted his profile since his last tenure as England head coach.
The Racing boss has expressed interest in coaching England again, although he’s also open to opportunities in the southern hemisphere. Lancaster’s RFU experience makes him a familiar and appealing choice for the role.
